5 Star Zillow Agent Nancy's Real Estate Team

Walking with you through the buying or selling process with your best interests at heart

The process of selling or buying a home can feel confusing, frustrating, and at times, overwhelming. Now imagine that a good friend, who’s knowledgeable, dedicated, and honest, is by your side the entire way to advise and support you.

  • Nancy Dewbrew

    Principal Broker

    Nancy is an eager, hard working broker/owner of Central Indiana Real Estate and Team Leader…

  • Cinder Hayden

    Broker Associate

    Cinder Hayden is an ambitious real estate agent for Central Indiana Real Estate, Nancy’s Real…

  • Arika Mayes

    Broker Associate

    Arika Mayes is a Broker Associate who has a passion for working with both buyers…

  • Kim Cole

    Broker Associate

    Kim Cole was born and raised in Morgan County; Kim is a graduate of Indiana…

Nancy Dewbrew

Principal Broker

Nancy is an eager, hard working broker/owner of Central Indiana Real Estate and Team Leader of Nancy’s Real Estate Team. Nancy was raised in Martinsville and settled in Mooresville where she has built her business. She built her business out of her love for real estate and has been truly blessed to be able to do what she loves to do for a living. She enjoys taking the time to get to know her clients in order to understand their wants, needs and expectations. Whether buying or selling the process can be stressful and a little overwhelming at times. She will walk you through every step and make sure you have a clear understanding of the process and your options in order for you to make the best decision for you and your family. She stays up to date on the current market conditions, new listings and all educational requirements. This allows her to better serve her clients and provide them with the most recent information and negotiate the best price and results. Serving Morgan and all surrounding counties. Nancy was the 2004 Morgan County Division President, Served on the Finance committee at MIBOR, Real Estate Academy of Leadership 2010, along with other social events and committees. Five Star Award winner 2019 & 2020, 2020 Market Leaders Forbes The 500 List.

Cinder Hayden

Broker Associate

Cinder Hayden is an ambitious real estate agent for Central Indiana Real Estate, Nancy’s Real Estate Team. Cinder grew up in West Texas, she moved to Indiana 23 years ago and has made this great state her home. Cinder believes that her passion for real estate as well as her love for making others happy is what it takes to be great at what she does. Before real estate Cinder owned her own successful company for 15 years. Prior to that she had a career as a licensed broker in the stock market. Always in the back of her mind and in her heart, she wanted to buy and sell houses. She decided to take the leap of faith and has been going strong doing what loves and making other’s dreams come true ever since.

Arika Mayes

Broker Associate

Arika Mayes is a Broker Associate who has a passion for working with both buyers and sellers. Arika believes that quick communication, personal skills and knowledge of inventory are just a few important assets required to make a successful Real Estate Broker. Arika has learned firsthand from her Managing Broker, Nancy on what it takes to be effective and proficient. Arika also plays a role in social media marketing within the office. She is responsible for building advertisement and marketing posts. Before discovering her love for Real Estate, Arika earned a Bachelor’s degree in Psychology from IUPUI and worked as a School Counselor. Arika is personable and patient when it comes to finding her clients the perfect home.

Kim Cole

Broker Associate

Kim Cole was born and raised in Morgan County; Kim is a graduate of Indiana University and has an extensive legal background as a litigation paralegal for nearly 20 years in Indianapolis and Atlanta, Georgia. In addition, she was a small business owner for 5 years in the food industry.  Her strong legal skills and title experience makes her a great asset to her clients and our team.

Nancy’s Real Estate Team understands that buying or selling a home in Central Indiana is more than just a transaction: it’s a life-changing experience.


Just Sold

Thanks to Arika and Nancy for their quick and smooth handling of the sale of our home. Everything went as described and was very trouble free and fast. Their knowledge of the market and its movement was spot on! Loved the app they set us up with to track the showings, appraisal and inspection appointments.

We highly recommend using Nancy and Team for your Real Estate Needs!

mayes56 Avatar

Nancy is excellent at her job. She helped us buy our home site unseen from Florida by FaceTiming with us. She then met us at the house prior to closing for a walk through. She insured all the details were taken care of for a successful on time closing.

AndreaHoogwerf Avatar

A very professional, effective and pleasant experience. Showings were arranged in advance, with the option to control the timing. I was happy with pricing and expeditious closing. None better than Nancy and crew.

StillCrazy78 Avatar

My realtor is knowledgeable and friendly. She was very responsive when I called or texted. Arika offered great customer service. We will use Arika again and refer her services to our family and friends.

zuser20141108052130152 Avatar

Arika Mayes with Nancy’s Reality Team was very knowledgeable, responsive, and made our first home buying experience as comfortable and stress free as it could be throughout the whole process! She was very flexible with our crazy schedules and went above and beyond to accommodate us and find us the perfect home. She was quick to answer any questions we had ...which was quite a few and helped make finding our dream home enjoyable. I would recommend her and her team to anyone and everyone.

zuser20150408232736713 Avatar

Cinder showed me a home in Speedway. I had already fell in love with it from the pictures. I was pretty much convinced I was going to buy it. After the walk through I had to obtain another pre approval and she got me in touch with a lender and before midnight struck that same day, I was preapproved and my purchase agreement was complete and signed by me. I did my walk through at four pm. The previous owners signed it before noon the next day. If there was something going on, she was on top of it! Excellent communication between me and her kept things moving very quickly and flawlessly. With the home being in such great shape, there was really no negotiating. But I'm confident if we would have had to do so, it probably would have been just as flawless as the rest of my experience in purchasing this home. There were some other facets to the sale that told me inside how right this home was for me. I would not hesitate to work with Cinder and Nancy again if I needed a real estate team. Cinder is very personable and sweet. I highly recommend working with these ladies, it will definitely take the stress out of purchasing your next home.

drgnhrt07081 Avatar

I would HIGHLY recommend Nancy for all of your real estate needs! Nancy is super easy going and down to earth which helps especially when the market is a bit crazy to deal with. She went WAY above and beyond to make our deal happen and we are forever grateful to her for the negotiating she did on our behalf. Her entire office is knowledgeable and helpful as well, which is a great benefit!

Anna Daniel Avatar
Anna Daniel

Nancy is wonderful. She was right by my side the entire home sale process. Her knowledge of the market was very evident and I believe she got me the best possible deal on my home. She made the entire process painless.

zachgoodbar10 Avatar

Nancy is a very good realtor. Knows what we wanted and helped us find the perfect home. We highly recommend her and her staff!! She also sold our home. She was always there for any questions we had.

blucas1961 Avatar

Nancy and her team are wonderful to work with. Nancy’s real estate knowledge and her negotiating skills make her the BEST to have working for you. We have used her in 4 different transactions both as buyer and seller. She is truly dedicated to her clients. We Love Nancy!!!

pops8631 Avatar

Love Nancy!! We bought a house with her in 2015 and now sold my moms house with her in Sep 2020. She’s great! Prompt, attentive, go-getter! We will definitely use her in the future if we move again!!

justine zuehlke64 Avatar
justine zuehlke64

Very prompt on her response, to my selling needs. Informative on all my paperwork. Great negotiating skills , on getting the most out of my house. She was very friendly and smart minded on all angles, getting me the best deal she could.

raymondbowling1980 Avatar

Arika was great throughout the whole process. knowledgeable and easy to work with, I highly recommend!! She worked really hard to find the perfect home for me

jerryhodge011 Avatar

I first met Arika in my neighborhood as she was showing a home to a client of hers. We struck up a conversation and I asked if she would keep an eye out on any properties for sale in my area. After several possibilities that were not the right fit I thought for sure she would give up on me, but to my delight, she not only did not give up on me she found for me the perfect property I was hoping to find. Upon further investigation it turns out that this property was only on the market for a couple of days and had several inquiries. Arika's speedy response to finding that listing, thinking of me and getting the information to me asap led to an immediate offer and sale. Thank you Arika for not giving up on me. Lets do it again.

bill5513 Avatar

Sender did a wonderful job of showing as houses that we were looking for and that were and are price range. She took extra time and care as we were 1st time home buyers to walk us through this steps of buying a new home. My fiance and myself could not have asked for a better agent

Trevor Havens Avatar
Trevor Havens

Aubrey is friendly and easy to communicate with. She is knowledgeable and was very helpful in the whole home purchase process. She was able to negotiate effectively and understood our needs. I would recommend her!

Jennifer Koller Avatar
Jennifer Koller

From start to finish Aubrey is beyond attentive to her clients needs. She goes above and beyond in answering questions as well as attaining requested information. She is very knowledgeable of Central Indiana. With this being our second real estate transaction I would HIGHLY recommend Aubrey Walters as your real estate agent.

user6553089 Avatar

Our agent, Aubrey, was outstanding! Found us the home we had been looking for! She made everything run so smoothly. Would recommend Nancy's real estate team to everyone

pcozine Avatar

Nancy and her team made our first home buying process as easy and stress free as imaginable. We had a home in mind when we went to her and they explained everything, step by step, from looking for a home to closing. She helped us find a lender and also make sure that we got all necessary documents submitted to them. Nancy’s team was always available to answer any questions or concerns. We will definitely go through them again when it comes up in our future.

BradTurner2 Avatar

Our experience with Nancy was beyond amazing.... she looked out for our best interest in each home we viewed, knew what we were looking for in a home and shared with us any concerns she thought could affect us. When our offer was accepted her communication and attention to detail was right on point. We could not have asked for a better experience. If you are looking to buy or sale she is the best choice for your realtor needs!

StevenTuddy Avatar
REAL ESTATE MARKET REPORTUse our Market Reports to inform your decisions before buying or selling real estate in Indiana

Don’t miss the chance to participate in the biggest giveaway of this year.

FREE REAL ESTATE MARKET REPORTUse our Market Reports to inform your decisions before buying or selling real estate in Indiana

Average property values, inventory, and market changes for Indiana